HomeEditorialsFeatureAbout UsGames
World

ICC Judges Order Closure of Afghanistan Investigation Covering Alleged US Crimes

Judges at the International Criminal Court (ICC) have ordered the closure of its original Afghanistan investigation, which covered alleged crimes by US forces, despite ongoing appeals by prosecutors challenging earlier decisions to separate parts of the inquiry. The move comes amid escalating US sanctions and demands for the court to abandon investigations involving American and Israeli officials.

BIONIC READING

In a Nutshell

  • The Afghanistan investigation, authorised in March 2020, covered alleged war crimes committed by Afghan government forces, the Taliban, US troops and the CIA, as well as the Islamic State Khorasan Province (IS-K), dating back to 2003.
  • On November 12, ICC judges ordered the closure of the original Afghanistan investigation after separating allegations against the Taliban into a new inquiry, Afghanistan II. The decision also closes the line of inquiry into alleged IS-K crimes.
  • Prosecutors have appealed the closure decision. Two earlier appeals challenging the separation of the Taliban investigation and the transfer of court records, including four arrest warrants, also remain pending before the Appeals Chamber.
  • The decision comes as Washington continues to sanction ICC officials and demands that the court end investigations involving US and Israeli nationals.

Context 

The ICC's Afghanistan investigation dates back to November 2017, when then-prosecutor Fatou Bensouda requested authorisation to investigate alleged crimes committed by all parties to the conflict. Judges initially rejected the request in 2019, but the Appeals Chamber overturned that decision in March 2020, allowing the investigation to proceed. In 2021, then-prosecutor Karim Khan deprioritised allegations involving US military and CIA personnel, as well as former Afghan government forces, citing difficulties in obtaining evidence, and shifted focus towards the Taliban and IS-K.

In November 2024, Chile, Costa Rica, Spain, France, Luxembourg and Mexico jointly referred further allegations against the Taliban concerning crimes against women and girls since its return to power in 2021 to the ICC Prosecutor. Judges subsequently ordered these allegations to be investigated separately. The new Afghanistan II investigation was opened on October 20, 2026, with four arrest warrants against senior Taliban officials transferred to it. The November 12 decision closes the record of the original Afghanistan investigation, while the Taliban inquiry continues separately.

The prosecution has challenged the separation of the Taliban investigation and the transfer of court records, with both appeals still pending before the Appeals Chamber. It has also appealed the November 12 closure decision. The outcome of these proceedings could determine whether the original investigation can be reopened or whether its closure will stand.

Why It Matters 

The closure also follows years of US retaliation against the court. In February 2025, Washington sanctioned Khan over the ICC's investigations involving American personnel and Israeli officials, including arrest warrants against Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant. Further sanctions targeted nine judges and other court officials, including members of the Appeals Chamber that authorised the Afghanistan investigation in 2020. The measures include asset freezes and restrictions on financial transactions and entry into the US.

On October 9, Washington escalated its campaign by announcing institutional sanctions against the ICC, giving the court a six-month grace period to address its demands before the measures take effect. These include closing the Afghanistan and Palestine investigations and amending the Rome Statute to prevent the prosecution of nationals from countries that have not joined the court. Secretary of State Marco Rubio has threatened to "dismantle the ICC, brick by brick". The grace period runs until April 2027, leaving the court under pressure as it considers how to respond.

What We Think 

The closure of the Afghanistan investigation comes at a time when the US is actively trying to weaken the ICC's ability to investigate its nationals and Israeli officials. Although judges cited the prosecution's inability to effectively pursue further investigative work, the decision risks reinforcing Washington's pressure campaign, particularly while appeals remain unresolved. The court's independence will also be tested by whether its member states resist demands to amend the Rome Statute to shield nationals of powerful non-member countries from prosecution.

░▒▓█▓▒░