HomeEditorialsFeatureAbout UsGames
Bangladesh

Do we really need Gram Sarkar? In conversation with Badiul Alam Majumdar

Governance campaigner Badiul Alam Majumdar says the country doesn't need it. He wants the councils we already have to work.

BIONIC READING

For most villagers, the Union Parishad member is the face of government. A draft law now on the table would put a new body beside that member, called Gram Sarkar.

The government wants a 17-member Gram Sarkar in every ward. The Local Government Division drew up the Gram Sarkar Act, 2026, and posted it on its website, along with email addresses to which anyone can send their views until 17 November.

Once the comment period ends, the draft goes to the Cabinet Division.

What the government has in mind

Each ward would get a body of 17 people. The ward's UP member would lead it, and the woman member elected to the reserved seat would be its adviser. The other 15 members would be chosen by a simple "yes" or "no" vote. At least 10 per cent of the ward's voters would have to turn up for that vote to count.

Officials say Gram Sarkar would help plan local development, build roads and other infrastructure, and deliver social protection. It would also help settle local disputes and keep an eye on how projects and money are being handled.

State Minister Mir Shahe Alam told The Daily Star earlier this month why it could matter. Birth and death registration is full of errors, he said, and grassroots representatives could help fix that. They could also help collect accurate data on nutrition and vaccination.

Officials stress that the draft isn't final. It still has to go through several stages before it becomes law.

"It is incomprehensible to me"

Badiul Alam Majumdar founded the civic group SHUJAN and headed the Electoral Reform Commission set up by the interim government. He has long argued for stronger local government. He was blunt in an interview with Nutshell Today.

"It is incomprehensible to me why the government is trying to establish Gram Sarkar"

— BADIUL ALAM MAJUMDAR, GOVERNANCE CAMPAIGNER

His reasoning starts with what already exists. "The existing tiers of our local government are dysfunctional," he said. "Day by day, they are becoming not only dysfunctional, but also irrelevant.

"Every past government took initiatives to make this local government system dysfunctional, and this government is doing the same."

— BADIUL ALAM MAJUMDAR, GOVERNANCE CAMPAIGNER

So why create something new? "We have no need for this at all," he said. "Right now, what is important is making the existing local government institutions effective."

The tool that was never switched on 

Badiul Alam Majumdar pointed to something already in the law: the Ward Shava, an open meeting where the people of a ward can question their representatives. "I myself had incorporated the Ward Shava into the Union Parishad Act," he said. "Through the Ward Shava, their transparency and accountability are supposed to be ensured, planning is supposed to happen at the local level, and decisions are supposed to be made locally."

But the Ward Shava, he said, "hasn't even been made functional yet. Hardly any initiative was taken for it."

That is why he doesn't think Gram Sarkar can fill any gap. "Through the Ward Shava, the members and chairmen of the Union Parishad are supposed to be held accountable. Yet this new body would be under their leadership," he said. "If they are going to put it under the ward member, let them activate the ward itself and activate those existing members instead."

A warning about division

His second worry is about the mood in the villages.

"Our society is already divided, and by establishing Gram Sarkar, it will become even more divided"

— BADIUL ALAM MAJUMDAR, GOVERNANCE CAMPAIGNER

He expects society to split along BNP, Awami League and Jamaat lines. "Within the Gram Sarkar structure, elections will be contested on a partisan basis," he said. "This party-based competition will further escalate fighting, local-level infighting, local terrorism and local unrest."

He also doesn't accept the comparison with the past. Of the first Gram Sarkar under the late President Ziaur Rahman, he said: "It did yield good results at that time. However, a lot of water has flowed under the bridge since then. We are now a divided nation."

Back then, he said, the aim was "organising everyone, uniting everyone, and fostering a collective effort for rural development."

Now, "it will only create division." If the government is treating what the past BNP government did as "sacrosanct", he added, "I do not think that will be right."

This part is his prediction. The draft itself describes a yes/no vote and doesn't say candidates would run under party symbols.

What he would do instead

Asked what specific steps the government should take, Badiul Alam Majumdar gave a short list.

  1. "First, elections must be held."
  2. "The honourable Members of Parliament must be kept away from local government."
  3. "Decentralisation of resources is needed. They must be allowed to work independently."
  4. "The Ward Shava system needs to be made effective."

Behind this is a simple idea, which experts call subsidiarity. "This principle states that the solution must lie where the problem is," he said. "Almost all of our problems are local, so these problems need to be solved through local government, through a government at the people's doorstep."

He also pointed to Article 59(2) of the Constitution, which he said "clearly states that the preparation and implementation of all plans relating to public services and economic development must be carried out through local government."

Then he put it this way: "The superstructure of democracy is built through Parliament. This superstructure cannot float on thin air."

What the record shows

"They are not holding elections, which is a violation of the Constitution," Badiul Alam Majumdar said.

It's true that no local elections have been held for more than two years. The Election Commission has now set a five-phase Union Parishad election schedule that runs from 21 January to 27 May 2027.

Giving MPs offices at the upazila level, he said, "is also a violation of the Constitution."

The minister described it more softly. In April, he told Parliament that each upazila parishad building would get a "visiting room" for the local MP.

The history is a bit tangled too. 

Ziaur Rahman's government first set up Gram Sarkar in 1980, and it was scrapped a few years later under HM Ershad. 

Khaleda Zia's BNP-led government brought it back with a new law in 2003, but the High Court declared that law unconstitutional in 2005. The Supreme Court then put the ruling on hold. 

In 2009, under Sheikh Hasina's Awami League government, Parliament scrapped the law. 

Now, Prime Minister Tarique Rahman's BNP government wants to bring Gram Sarkar back.

Not everyone agrees with him 

Some see promise in the idea. Former secretary AKM Abdul Awal Mazumder says it is a good initiative if honest and capable people run it. But he told The Daily Star it should be tested in a few areas first, before it goes nationwide.

The question for you 

Is something missing from our villages, or do the councils we already have simply lack the power to do their job?

Badiul Alam Majumdar says it's the second.

Of everything the Ward Shava was meant to deliver, he said: "All of these are supposed to happen, yet none of them is anywhere near being implemented. Instead, they are trying to create another structure."

The government sees it differently, and its final answer is still to come.

The deadline is close, so if you have a view, now is the time to send it.

░▒▓█▓▒░